當(dāng)AI越來越聰明、越來越方便，人的價值究竟如何體現(xiàn)？

最近，深圳市南山外國語學(xué)校（集團(tuán)）高級中學(xué)的語文老師于雅萱給學(xué)生出了一道特別的題：

“用一個字證明你不是AI，你會選哪個字？”

"Prove you're not an AI with one Chinese character. What would you choose?"

54份問卷收回來，答案讓老師倍感驚喜。消息一經(jīng)發(fā)布，更打動了廣大網(wǎng)友。原來，最能證明“我是人”的，從來不是效率和正確，而是那些AI學(xué)不會的東西。

有人選“媽”，“這是大多數(shù)人學(xué)會的第一個詞，象征了一種守護(hù)的魔法。父母是我們與死亡之間的最后一道防線，而機(jī)器人沒有媽媽?！?/p>

"It is the first word most humans learn and a symbol of protective magic. Parents are the last line of defense between us and death. But robots don't have one."

有人選“急”，“醫(yī)院出報(bào)告要 30 分鐘，為什么病人每隔幾分鐘就去看？人類并非活在純粹客觀的時間里，我們對時間的感知是由情感塑造的?！?/p>

"It takes 30 minutes for a hospital to issue test results, so why do patients check every few minutes? Humans do not live in purely objective time. Our experience of time is shaped by emotion."

也有人選“慢”，“AI永遠(yuǎn)在追求更快更準(zhǔn)，而我卻希望人能慢慢走路，慢慢說話，慢慢長大，我愿意把時間浪費(fèi)在美好的事物上?！?/p>

"AI endlessly pursues speed and accuracy, but I wish for humans to walk slowly, speak slowly and grow up slowly. I am willing to waste time on things that make life beautiful."

有人選“疑”，“AI會質(zhì)疑它的創(chuàng)造者嗎？”

"Will AI doubt its creator?"

有人選“限”，“人工智能是無限的，而我的一切都是有限的——我所學(xué)的知識、遇見的人、聽過的故事，我的生命與時光。人工智能因無限而珍貴，而我因有限而更顯珍貴?！?/p>

"AI is infinite, but everything about me is finite — the knowledge I've learnt, the people I've met, the stories I've heard, my life and my time. AI is valuable because it is infinite, while I am even more precious because I am finite."

“我”是自我意識，“痛”是活著的證明，“恨”是矛盾情感的復(fù)雜交織，“悔”是成長的痕跡，“膽”是明知不可為而為之的勇氣......

于老師說，這道題表面上是在區(qū)分人與AI，但它的真正意圖其實(shí)是邀請每個人向內(nèi)看?！癆I像一面無比清晰的鏡子，映照出我們正因習(xí)以為常而輕易忽略的屬于‘人’的瞬間，那些猶豫的、笨拙的、沖動的、柔軟的片刻。我們并非要通過簡單的對比陷入‘人與AI’的優(yōu)劣之爭，而是想以鏡鑒的方式抵達(dá)那些珍貴的人性深處。”

"AI is like a clear mirror, reflecting those distinctly human moments we easily overlook because they seem ordinary — hesitation, clumsiness and impulsiveness. The goal is not to fall into a simplistic debate over whether humans or AI are superior, but to use this mirror to reach the deeper, more precious layers of our humanity."

于老師選的字是“你”。

她援引了毛主席的名言：“世界是你們的，也是我們的，但是歸根結(jié)底是你們的?！庇诶蠋熣f，“世界的未來，終將由你們這樣年輕的心靈來書寫，用這樣澄澈的眼睛去觀看，用這樣靈巧的雙手去創(chuàng)造。”

"The future will be written by young minds, seen through their clear eyes and created by hands as nimble as theirs."

于老師將課堂討論的視頻發(fā)布在B站上，獲得了670萬播放量、37萬點(diǎn)贊和3.6萬條評論。許多網(wǎng)友稱贊學(xué)生們的思想深度，并分享了自己的答案。

隨著人工智能在各行業(yè)快速普及，人類與AI的聯(lián)系愈發(fā)緊密。漢語盤點(diǎn)將“深度求索（DeepSeek）” 評為2025年度國內(nèi)詞。

China's annual Chinese language review named "DeepSeek", a homegrown AI model, as the country's phrase of the year for 2025.

“我們處于一個科技浪潮迅速席卷的時代，我們享受AI帶來的便捷，也會產(chǎn)生一些隨之而來的焦慮。我想，打動人的可能并不是一節(jié)課，而是這些答案和思考背后那些無法被數(shù)字化掩蓋的人性微光。”于老師說。

"We live in an era swept by fast-moving technological waves. We enjoy the convenience AI brings, but we also feel anxiety. What truly moves people may not be a single class, but the faint glimmers of humanity revealed in these answers — glimmers that cannot be erased by digitalization."

有學(xué)生表示，她并不擔(dān)心被AI取代。

“我支配目的，而AI受目的支配。AI永遠(yuǎn)在回答，而人一直在追問。”

"I shape purpose, while AI is shaped by purpose. AI is always answering, but humans are always questioning."

用一個字證明你不是AI，你會選哪個？

在評論區(qū)留下你的答案。

記者：陳美玲 陳虹

跟著China Daily

精讀英語新聞

“無痛”學(xué)英語，每天20分鐘就夠！